Three green things that shouldn’t mingle

This comes directly from my ‘what not to do’ column: Never mix hydrogen peroxide and vinegar and seal them in a container. But before I knew this was a bad, bad idea, I’d learned that peroxide and vinegar can be combined to form a sanitizer that is better than bleach. So, me being me, I went right to my cupboard and pulled out a large bowl, thinking I’d mix up a new and improved version of my DIY cleaning wipes solution.  I had everything ready when my husband walked by and asked, “Are you sure it’s safe to mix peroxide and vinegar?” This annoyed me because, well…I’m not sure why. But I stopped what I was doing and Googled the question.

Turns out, it was good he asked.

Here’s what I learned.

Hydrogen Peroxide

The good news: The fizzy substance that costs a couple of bucks for a brown bottle is on the EPA’s list of sanitizers. That means it can kill 99.9% of germs, like some strains of E.Coli, flu, and mold. It’s also not harmful to the planet and, unless you seal it in a mason jar with something it shouldn’t be mixed with, the 3:97 peroxide:water ratio available at grocery stores is generally harmless for us. You could even use it as a mouth rinse. (To read an article about the many uses for peroxide in Truth or Fiction click here.)

A word of warning: Greater ratios of HP to water are available at health food stores; but the purer the hydrogen peroxide the more dangerous it CAN be. (The 3% solution is potent enough to do most jobs, besides.) And, peroxide should NEVER be mixed with vinegar and sealed in a container. That can cause a chemical change that could form the highly corrosive peracetic acid. A whiff of that could damage a person’s lungs!

Back to the good news: But, from Michael and Judy Stouffer’s blog I learned that the chemical reaction that can occur when peroxide and vinegar are put into a container does not happen if they are combined in other ways. In fact, when the two liquids are kept in separate spray bottles and applied to a surface as a mist one after another, they actually become a safe and effective sanitizer.

In Michael and Judy’s article I read about a food scientist at Virginia Polytechnic Institute who’d researched this. She reported that when used sequentially this way, a peroxide and vinegar combination is safe enough to clean vegetables and fruit with,  while at the same time powerful enough to kill virtually all Salmonella, Shigella, or E. coli bacteria on heavily contaminated surfaces. The latter was confirmed by tests done at two universities.

This combo is even safe if accidentally consumed. And, if you’re worried about your strawberries tasting like vinegar, the taste and smell won’t linger. In fact, vinegar is a pretty good neutralizer of odors. That said, the recommendation is to spray the fruit with the two agents in a sort one-two punch, let the combo sit on the surface for a few seconds, then rinse.  The article claims that this spray combination is more effective for killing germs than chlorine bleach or any commercially available kitchen cleaner.

My next move

41zutfylr6l-_ac_ul115_I bought some misting spray bottles and plan to label two as either being for ‘peroxide,’ or ‘vinegar.’ (I want to be careful about mixing up the bottles when I refill them. Also, I chose aluminum, rather than clear bottles because I wanted something that would block out sunlight, which can cause peroxide to break down.)  (Click here if you’d like to check the bottles out on amazon.) I plan to use the one-two punch for my dishes. I’ve been concerned for some time about bacteria there, because we don’t own a dishwasher.

The moral to the story

Even along the journey to a greener lifestyle there are dangers to be aware of. I should never have assumed that two planet-friendly agents would be harmless when combined. There are also uses for even the most mild green cleaner that should be avoided. It’s important to stop and check. So, the next time I play mad scientist, I’ll Google the question: ‘is it safe…’ before I break out my mixing bowl.

Click here to read a blog post about more cleaners that don’t mix.

 

Germs vs. DIY Cleaning Wipes

For those of you on the edge of your seats wondering how my WetJet Swiffer now works with a sock soaked in Dr. Bronner’s solution on the head instead of a Swiffer pad, let’s just say it doesn’t exactly glide img_1550across the floor like it used to. Also, the plastic mop handle makes a terrible cracking sound each time I push on it. On the bright side, the sock picks up more dirt than the paper pad had and I can wash and reuse it. I figure if the mop handle breaks, duct tape can fix anything.

In regard to the DIY vinegar wipes, I’m still in love with them. Several friends have said they liked the smell, too, and one told me that img_1558her hands don’t feel dry after she cleans with them. I’d forgotten how my fingers would become powdery and dry from the chemicals in the Member’s Mark Disinfecting Wipes.

But after running around the house cleaning with my new wipes all week, I’ve remade several batches and have learned a few things. For starters, I’d originally suggested using 1/3 cups of vinegar and water, but I’ve found it best to use a little more than that, so that all the rags absorb the fluid. Also, for saturation purposes I now soak the cleaning cloths in the liquid before stuffing them into the mason jar. And finally, I’ve added lemon juice to the recipe. It helps improve the smell and I read somewhere that it can cut through grease. (See updated recipe here)

I’ll likely update it again soon, though. I did my homework and now know how to help boost the anti-microbial benefits of the wipes without using chemicals. I’ll blog about that next week. For now, here’s a bit about germs and how my DIY wipes hold up against them.

A bit about germs

images-1Germs are a category for things like viruses, bacteria, parasites, mold and fungi. They’re in every space that living organisms occupy. That means, while I’m sitting on my exercise ball at my desk, drinking coffee and typing on my laptop, I’m sharing every inch of that space with thousands of micro-organisms. But in a way, all those crazy little bugs that I can’t see have made me who I am.

Viruses are sometimes called pathogens. We can catch a virus, like a cold or the flu, by coming into contact with someone who’s sick. But they also hang out on surfaces, like door handles, shopping cart handles, cell phones, counter tops, or they can travel through the air. Each of us are probably exposed to viruses many times a day without realizing it. We don’t always get sick because, if we’ve been around the viruses before, our immune systems have likely learned how to fight them.

imagesAnother name for bacteria is microbes. E. coli and strep are examples of bacteria that can make us sick. But there are bacteria that keep us healthy, too.  In fact,  we all carry our own unique ecosystem of bacteria on, in and around us.  (To watch a video on the fascinating research being conducted by the Home Microbiome Project click here .)

Resistant Bacteria

Scientists are desperate to find images-2germ fighters that are more potent than the ones currently available. The problem is, overuse of antibiotics and disinfectants have made many viruses and bacteria resistant to the stuff that used to kill them. Just like our bodies learn how to fight the germs we’ve been exposed to, with enough exposure to sanitizing agents and antibiotics, germs learn how to stay healthy, too.

Common Sense and Good Cleaning Habits

Some folks need to be very careful about germs. For people with underdeveloped or weak immune systems a common cold could turn into something far worse. They might have to use chemicals that kill germs on contact. Daycares, hospitals, and facilities that have a public restroom might need to use bleach and other fast-acting disinfectants because the risk of spreading sicknesses is higher in those places.

But for me, routine cleaning habits in my homes, safe food handling and knowledge of how germs spread should be enough to keep me and my husband healthy. Maybe those products that kill 99.9% of germs should be used only when I know contamination of surfaces by harmful bacteria is likely; like when I splatter raw eggs on the kitchen counter or sneeze of all over my keyboard. Because then, I don’t want to spread live germs around and risk cross contaminating surfaces. But with the way I was using disinfecting wipes in my kitchen, the frequent exposure to chemical sanitizers could have made me sick in different ways than the germs had without me even realizing it. Plus, when I need to rely on these heavy-duty germ killers, I want them to work.

So, how do my DIY cleaning wipes hold up against germs?

The vinegar wipes contain two germ fighters: vinegar and lavender. Vinegar has been proven effective against some strains of the flu. It also worked well for removing the mold on my pet’s doggie door. Lavender can kill certain fungi and some germs, as well. With the two combined, they likely do all right for routine cleanings. They just don’t kill 99.9% of microbes to qualify as sanitizers, and they don’t kill the really bad stuff, like salmonella.

But here’s the good news. There are green cleaners that can kill those kinds of germs. And, theres a dynamite combination that’s green and can disinfect as well as bleach! But that’s for next week’s article.

Think green and I’ll see you then!

DIY cleaning wipes

I’ll confess that I’m not much of a do-it-yourselfer. That said, now that I’ve made my own cleaning wipes, I’m a little in love with the idea. It’s super easy to put together a jar full.  Plus, they’re just as easy to use as the Member’s Mark Disinfecting Wipes my husband buys from Sam’s Club. All I needed to do was cut up one of his old t-shirts instead of throwing it away, put some vinegar or Dr. Bronner’s castile soap, water, and an essential oil into a pitcher and pour it into a mason jar on top of the rags.

Here’s the recipe I used. There are also many on-line to choose from.

RECIPE FOR DIY CLEANING WIPES USING VINEGAR 

1, 1.5 cup size mason jarIMG_1499

 

 

Enough cut up t-shirts or socks etc. IMG_1504to stuff it full

 

 

1/3 cup vinegar, (it can be a little on the heavy

side)IMG_1502

 

 

IMG_15011/3 cup water

 

 

img_15641/3 cup lemon juice

 

 

 

 

 

About 10 eyedroppers full of lavender or other nice IMG_1503smelling essential oil

 

Mix liquids into a bowl or pitcher. Put enough rags to fill the mason jar into the liquid to saturate them. Stuff mason jar img_1558full of rags.  Put lid on and tighten. Flip jar a couple of times so the liquid spreads. Store in dark area. (I keep a jar in cabinets under our kitchen and bathroom sinks.)

 

RECIPE FOR WIPES USING DR. BRONNER’Simg_1557

1, 1.5 cup size mason jar

Cut up t-shirts and socks, etc.

Three squirts of Dr. Bronner’s soap

1/3 cup of water

Follow same directions as a above.

 

HERE’S WHAT I LIKE ABOUT BOTH

They’re convenient for light cleaning. I use the vinegar ones on my formica counters, stove, fridge, mirrors, windows, and for wiping around in the downstairs bathroom. The Dr. Bronner’s wipes work well, too. A little goes a long way with it!

They get rid of dirt. I used the Dr. Bronner’s wipes on my bathtub and the ring inside it dissolved after just a little rubbing. The vinegar ones cleaned the smudges off the bottom of my front door and left my bathroom mirror shinyimg_1550. Also, I cut up some of my husband’s socks that he was going to throw out. They fit perfectly over the head of my WetJet Swiffer. (At first, my husband couldn’t figure out why I was so excited about old socks.) I put them in a mason jar with the Dr. Bronner’s solution. They  worked great for cleaning my hardwood floors. Now I have reusable, washable Swiffer pads instead of disposable ones!

They’re better for the environment. Both vinegar and Dr. Bronner’s are plant based and are harmless to people, pets and the planet. Plus, the cloth wipes can be washed and reused instead of thrown away after a single use, which means we’re not adding more non-biodegrable trash to landfills. After I clean with one of the rags, I just toss it into my bin of used cleaning cloths. When the bin fills up I run a load of laundry in hot water and bleach.

HERE’S WHAT’S NOT SO GREAT

Vinegar can damage stone and tile.  It’s fine to use on some surfaces, like formica and glass, but not on others, like stone and tile. Because of its acidity, it can cause streaking in stone and can eat away grout on tiled surfaces. I also wouldn’t use it on my wood floors. But the Dr. Bronner’s wipes are fine to use anywhere.

Dr. Bronner’s is expensive. My husband nearly blew a fuse when I told him I paid $33.00 for a half-gallon jug of soap. “But we can use it for everything from doing dishes to cleaning our pets,” I said.  The fact that I would use it for more than just wipes didn’t help him come around.

Neither works as a sanitizer. There’s a difference between cleaning, sanitizing and disinfecting. In terms of cleaning, which simply means removing dirt from a surface, both the  vinegar and Dr. Bronner’s do the job. But they don’t kill 99.9% of germs to qualify as sanitizers.  Disinfecting is even a step above that. A disinfectant kills 100% of microbes. But, from what I’ve read about microbes, they’re a part of life. In fact, exposure to them might help strengthen our immune systems. Unless my husband and I worked in a hospital or chicken coop, where we risked bringing home germs like streptococcus on our clothing, I really don’t need to keep sanitizing surfaces in our home ten times a day the way I’ve been. Repeated exposure to anti-microbial cleaners isn’t good for us either.

But we do occasionally prepare raw meat, chicken, and fish, which can leave germs like salmonella on our kitchen counter. I also work with toddlers, so I need to sanitize the toys I use. And, let’s not forget our four animals, that can scamper through the doggie door with germs like E. coli on their paws. There are a few agents that the EPA says work well enough to kill those kinds of germs. Of them, bleach is considered the best. But the chemical can be hard on the environment and on people’s health. There are plant based options available, though. I’ll get into that next week.

Neither cleaner will remove mold. That’s another job for bleach. But if there’s a green alternative, I’d prefer to use it. I’ll find out about that for next week, too.

The smell of the vinegar is not for everyone.  My husband keeps repeating the same question every time he walks through the laundry room: “That smell doesn’t bother you?” I’ll admit, the lavender maybe takes the solution from having a very, very strong vinegar smell to just a very strong vinegar smell. It still makes my eyes tear. On the other hand, Dr. Bronner’s comes in pleasant smelling fragrances or fragrance free. I bought the peppermint-scented soap. It smells nice.

FINAL THOUGHTS

In my opinion both types of cleaning wipes work fine as alternatives to disposable ones for cleaning at home and each would be good to have around for different tasks. But if my husband really hates the smell of vinegar, the Dr. Bronner’s soap version can work anywhere and is excellent. (He said he would suffer the smell if it meant not spending big bucks on soap. What he doesn’t realize is, though vinegar is cheaper it can’t be used everywhere the way Dr. Bronner’s can. The way I see it, we’ll be saving money on Swiffer pads and cleaning wipes, so the cost will balance out.) I will need to look into some kind of green sanitizing agents for home and on the job, though. That’s my homework for next week’s post.

See you then!

 

 

 

 

Green Labels

Here’s something I wish I’d known about before having started this blog. There’s a database called  GoodGuide, which verifies the greenness of lots of companies. I stumbled upon it this past week, during my search for a green alternative to the disposable cleaning wipes my husband and I use.  Not long before that, I’d spent half an hour in the cleaning product section of Price Chopper comparing disinfecting wipe labels.  I realized then that the level of scrutiny needed to read between the lines there was enough to make me nauseas.

It would make things a lot easier on my journey towards a greener lifestyle imagesif I could rely on product labels. But, like with the organic food industry, where if a manufacturer uses a few organic ingredients it can label its products ‘organic’, a company can get away with printing ‘green’ on product labels by being just a little environmentally friendly.  Am I wrong for hating that I have to play super sleuth to figure out which ‘green’ products are truly green?

The other day I came home from Price Chopper with a brand of wipes called Sun & Earth in my 41MjBbWmHxL._AC_US160_reusable cloth shopping bag. It seemed like a great option. The wipes smelled like citrus and cleaned well enough. The label on them listed all  ingredients and shared the many ways in which they were environmentally safe, cruelty free, and safe to use. I didn’t stop with reading it, though. I went on the Sun and Earth‘s website and learned that the company had been in business since the 1980’s and had held an eco-conscious core value from the beginning. They also have lots of different cleaning products, some which Price Chopper carries! I was so ready to retire my magnifying glass and become a loyal customer.

But then I should have stopped there.

The thing is, I needed to find out if there were independent ratings or blog post reviews for Sun & Earth.  That’s when my Google search led me to GoodGuide, which will now be my go-to site for verifying green claims. GoodGuide scientists rate products on a 0 to 10 scale for health, environment, and social impact. They gave Sun & Earth  just 4’s for environment because of some ingredients and company practices. Off S & E’s label and website, I would never have guessed that.

Surprisingly, the cleaning wipes for Green Works, which is owned by Clorox received 7.5. Seventh Generation also scored well97-PRODUCT_01-754_814-1392313962869.  GoodGuide also gave high ratings to products from a soap company called Dr. Bronners, which, as I’ve since learned from my daughter, anyone who leads a green lifestyle knows about.

Dr. Bronner’s makes something called Castile soap: 41pLIP1lq8L-1._AC_US160_a plant-based soap that is safe for the planet and can be used for 14 different household and personal hygiene tasks, according to the company. Here’s the good news, (although my husband may not agree,) with Dr. Bronner’s we could potentially jump way ahead in terms of making our lives greener. We could use Dr. Bronner’s to wash our dishes, scrub our cars, clean our floors, do our laundry, wash our hands; all things for which we currently use products that are not environmentally friendly. We could even brush our teeth with it (although the thought of that makes me gag a little).  But what I’m most excited about right now is that I can use Dr. Bronner’s to make a solution for my own reusable cloth cleaning wipes. YAY! Click here to find out how.

So, I am officially turning in my sleuthing cap and leaving the green detective work to GoodGuideUnknown. I’d rather dress up in goggles and a lab coat anyway! For next week: DIY cleaning wipes, unless of course, I blow myself up.

 

 

 

 

Are disposible cleaning wipes hurting our planet?

Who doesn’t love quick clean ups?

Let me start by saying that, like many Americans, I love cleaning wipes because they’re convenient. I just images-1flip the lid up on the yellow Member’s Mark Disinfecting Wipes canister that I keep near my kitchen sink, pull out a square sheet of non-woven fiber and with a swipe of my hand obliterate 99% of germs like salmonella from my kitchen counter. It also makes my kitchen smell lemony. When I’m done, I just drop the wipe into the trash.

A top seller in a gazillion forms 

It makes sense then that what started out in the 1970’s as a way for mommies on the go to wipe their images-3baby’s behinds has grown to a multi-million dollar industry aimed at satisfying all our cleaning needs. These days, there are wipes to clean our faces, pets, eye glasses, car interiors, computers, dust off furniture, wipe down floors and showers, and so on and so forth. They’re used in schools, hospitals and businesses, and nearly half the households in North America have some forms of disposable wipes on their weekly shopping lists. In short, since the 1990’s when sales of the time-saving dynamos really took off, the use of cleaning wipes in their many forms has become a way of life for people all over the world.

The life of a wipe doesn’t end with the trash can

But now that so many of us are using them, like with single-use plastic shopping bags, discarded wipes are washing up on beaches wet_wipes_littering_uk_beaches_up_50_25and hanging around in landfills. The problem is, the majority of them don’t biodegrade either. And,  like plastic bags, when cleaning wipes float around on the surface of our oceans they look a lot like tasty jelly fish to sea turtles and other animals, which eat them,  get sick, and die. images The wipes have also been known to clog sewer lines, although it does say on the containers not to flush them.

Anti-bacterial everywhere!

Also, like with plastic bags from where inks, dyes, and other chemicals act as toxins when they seep from them into the ground and waterways, the chemicals and fragrances on cleaning wipes bleed too.  But the agents that make many disposable wipes anti-bacterial present other problems when they hit the ground and water. Just like they can kill 99% of bacteria in our kitchens, they kill bacteria everywhere. But some bacteria is necessary; like the ones that help garbage break down in landfills.

A public health crisis?

If that’s not bad enough, the chemicals in cleaning wipes and other cleaning products these days can cause health problems for some people that range from allergic reactions to auto-immune conditions. There are also doctors who are concerned that our extensive use of anti-bacterial agents could actually make our immune systems less capable of fighting harmful bacteria and viruses.

And let’s not forget Charles Darwin

Then there’s that little old Theory of Natural Selection, if you believe in that sort of thing.

tips to throw theperfectsurpriseparty!-3

‘Super bugs,’  sound like science fiction, but they’re not. They’re what happens when bacteria grow resistant to antibiotics and the anti-bacterial chemicals in so many of the cleaning and personal hygiene products we use. They may be microscopic, but they could really make us sick. Then we might have to come up with stronger ways to zap them and that could wreak more havoc on everything and everyone. With that in mind, maybe we should rethink our drive to kill germs everywhere and accept that there are germs in our homes and in other places that we could most likely live with and still be healthy.

A change of heart

More and more I’m learning that if a product is made to be used once and tossed, it’s going to cause problems for Mother Earth. For me, that’s enough of a reason to end my love affair with disposable cleaning wipes. Now I just have to find out about eco-friendly alternatives, and see which ones would be a good fit for my husband and me.

Until next week.

Comments: Always welcome. Always appreciated. If you would like to share an insight, experience, or ask a question, please include the words ‘cleaning wipes’ in your message. This will help me distinguish real comments from spam.

Thank you.

Clueless Girl

Comments Anyone?

THE APOLOGY

To anyone out there kind enough to have ever commented on a Clueless Girl post, thank you.  I’m sorry if I haven’t replied to you. The thing is, within the past months, more and more I’ve been marking comments on this website as spam. That’s because, and this is a lesson I’ve learned from running this blog, sometimes spam looks a lot like a comment.

THE BACKSTORY

I started Clueless Girl on Earth Day 2016 and during those first weeks and months I would get so excited whenever the ‘comment’ icon on my admin page had a number next to it. It meant a live person had actually read my blog! Those days it was mostly notes of encouragement from my mother and a few friends. I never questioned whether their comments were real. I just happily responded.

That changed after I’d blogged about how plastic shopping bags were polluting the planet, and I received a message from someone I didn’t know. It was in Chinese, too, which made me very curious.  So, I copied and pasted the long paragraph into Google Translator. That’s when I found out that the comment wasn’t a comment at all.  It was just a bunch of advertisements.

I was disappointed. It would have been cool to get a comment from China. But also, the spam-blocker program I use should have stopped the ad from getting through to my admin page. Instead, it left it for me to decide whether to click ‘accept and reply’ to publish it or to ‘mark as spam,’ and send it to wherever spam winds up. With this one, as well as with the many similar ads I’ve received almost every day since, the choice was obvious.

But there are more subtle ones that get through, as well. They say off topic things like: ‘Hey man, stop posting so many videos and just write.‘ (I’ve never published a video on Clueless Girl and I think I’ve included links to maybe 2 videos in all my posts.) Or they tell me how amazing my blog is, but make no mention of the post they’re attached to. I’ve responded to a few of the latter ones, of course.  I appreciate it when someone takes the time to say they like my blog, even if they do write with an accent and are weirdly over the top about it. So, it probably shouldn’t surprise anyone to know that after I replied with a thank you, there came a wave of similar weirdly over the top comments. Now I know that these too are a form of spam. What I can’t figure out is what they accomplish. I never click on any of the links in them. They just bug me.

Not long ago a comment came through that asked for my help. The writer said he was a new blogger. He requested some tips. FROM ME? I’m a new blogger too, so I don’t know much. But I wanted to support and encourage him.  I offered advice about maintaining a writing schedule, which for me is important because not only do I research and write for this blog, but I’m also working on my second novel in a sci-fi detective series, and I teach part-time for my local Early Intervention Program. Then I clicked ‘accept and reply’. Well. Guess what. Not long after, I got hit with a wave of similar requests for help.

I’d been duped.

THE PROBLEM 

I’m grateful to anyone who takes the time out of their day to read my blog.  If they then leave a remark or word of encouragement, I consider that a great gift for which I want to reciprocate by writing a reply.  My intention when I started Clueless Girl was to respond to every comment received. I still want to do that! The problem is, I can’t tell the real ones from the fakes.

THE SOLUTION

So, I was thinking: what if we had a code word that the spammers wouldn’t know about? I stock-vector-beautiful-brunette-girl-winking-and-making-silence-or-secret-hand-gesture-with-finger-on-lips-169363778could put something like that at the bottom of every post. That way, if someone wanted to offer an insight or ask me a question or just tell me about their experiences, if they included it in their comment I would know it was legit!

So, here it goes.

THE CODE WORD(S)

I know I won’t get an ‘A’ for creativity here, but if anyone would like to leave a comment on this post, please include the words ‘not spam’ in your message.

Thank you all so much for reading.

For next week: The Problem with Cleaning Wipes.

A Shout-out to the NRDC!

My husband says I’m too over the top about toilet paper. He could be right. I’ve just spent hours driving myself crazy reading web articles on the topic because, while I’ve learned more than I’d wanted to about how bamboo or hemp or sugarcane are the greenest things since fresh air, I could find little about the environmental impact of processing these alternatives to wood fibers.  Plus, none of the articles have told me whether or not the bisphenol A (BPA) found in TP made from recycled products could hurt us.

So I emailed some of the toilet paper companies. Then, after no one got back to me –––no one––– I emailed the Natural Resource Defense Counsel. The NRDC is a non-profit organization that works to safeguard the earth––its people, its plants and animals and the natural system on which all life depends.  (I copied that off their website.) To be honest, I hadn’t expected to hear back from them either.

I was wrong.

That same day I received the nicest email from Samuel Wicks, the counsel’s Public Education Associate. In it he answered all of my questions in a very courteous and professional manner that made me feel as if he cared about how I’m trying to make my life greener one corner of one room at one time. He also included articles.

So here’s the short of it:

Are TPs made from raw materials other than wood actually greener?

Bamboo  is used to make a variety of things; including textiles and paper. For paper goods, it is pulped into fiber by way of either mechanical or chemical processing. As a Unknowngeneral rule, mechanical processing can be more costly, but is better for the environment. The chemical processing methods used can actually harm the planet. That said, most bamboo manufacturers claim to be green, but really aren’t, because they use chemicals to turn bamboo stalks into fiber.

Hemp is another alternative to wood for paper and according to some of the articles I’ve read, it is generally made using images chemicals that aren’t as harsh to the environment. Both hemp and bamboo are not grown in high enough quantities in the US, though. That means the raw materials for products made from them would have to be shipped in from other countries, like China. This not only makes them more expensive, but increases their negative impact on the planet.

Sugarcane is grown on this continent and turning it into paper isn’t a new idea. I found this nifty video on making sugarcane paper from back in the 1950’sUnknown-1 It’s about 2 minutes long. (Click the underlined sentence above to watch it.) My favorite part is when the narrator says that sugar is one of our most important foods! But it looks like chemicals are needed during various stages of processing that plant into fiber, too.

TP from post-consumer recycled paper is the safest bet for the environment in terms of use of resources and processing. Plus,   the NRDC has a list of green tissue products.  There are plenty to choose from. But with that, I’m back to the BPA conundrum.  The way I see it, I’m left with two options: I go TP golden birthdayparty essentials-2free, install a bidet and use wash clothes. This option would be by far the greenest. I hadn’t mentioned it because,  I don’t know what I would do with my husband then. Or, I could shrug off my concerns and return to plan A: TP made from recycled content.

How bad is BPA exposure really? 

The answer is, it all seems sort of speculative, with some people raising the roof with concerns and other saying: it’s not so bad.  But one thing is certain: almost all of us have been exposed for generations. I suppose then most folks (with the exception of ME) figure there’s no point in dwelling on it.

According to one of the articles Samuel had sent, 98% of our exposure to BPA comes from contact with #’s 3-7 plastics, anyway. I don’t know if that makes it all okay, but at least then only 2% of our exposure comes from using recycled paper products. And, with the latter, the powdered version of the chemical is not a coating on the surface, like it is when I take my receipt after the cashier at Price Chopper hands it to me.  It seems people who handle receipts frequently should be most concerned. But in terms of recycled paper, the traces of BPA powder are mixed in with the slurry before it’s even turned into TP or other products.

So, what’s my final answer?

My husband and I are going to stay with Marcal for now. But we do plan to try a few of the different brands of toilet paper from the NRDC list. Green Forest is said to be somewhat softer compared to most recycled based TPs. It also received high marks on Greenpeace USA’s list of green TP’s.  Unfortunately, it’s not available in our supermarket. But Marcal is!

With that, my husband will be very happy to hear that next week’s post will be about Clorox wipes.

If you would like to make a tax-deductible donation to the NRDC, here’s the link to their website: https://www.nrdc.org